Brownstone is a realist fiction graphic novel about a 14-year-old girl named Almudena. The story follows her as she struggles to navigate having to spend a whole summer with her dad who she has never met, and who speaks virtually no English.
She slowly warms up to her father as they progress through working on apartment repairs together. Almudena ends up meeting Idola who helps translate between Almudena and her father. However, Almudena resents the fact that Idola is her father’s girlfriend, and is resistant to the fact that her parents will likely never get back together again.
Almudena struggles to fit in with the other people living in the city, since she grew up with little to no knowledge of her Guatemalan heritage. She is confused and frustrated with the criticism she’s received due to her lack of knowledge for her Guatemalan history, but she eventually grows and matures enough to realize that she doesn’t need the validation of others to feel good in her own skin.
Although I really loved all the illustrations of the characters and architecture, I have a lot of gripes with the actual story of this book. A lot of the story in question felt very rushed to me, and I get it’s hard to portray character growth in such a short graphic novel, but I found myself rather frustrated by the rushed development in the characters that it didn’t feel very cohesive.
Minor spoilers ahead but I just had to about it because it really stuck out to me. There is a point in the story were Almudena gets close with this woman named Queralt who owns the convenience store on the block, and when Idola comes in the store, she says she doesn’t want Almudena to hang out with her anymore because she’s a lesbian. Although I don’t think it’s necessarily wrong to include homophobia in a story, my issue with this piece of plot is that the two characters make up seamlessly a bit after this interaction with very little insight on Idola’s part, or even any further commentary on Idola’s homophobia, and why she acts this way or why she suddenly no longer had issues with it. The story even includes another queer character named Beto who is Idola’s son, which I thought was going to be used as an instance to portray Idola’s growth by supporting him, but it’s just kind of mentioned and then moved on from. I often like when queer characters aren’t just focused on for their queerness but this just felt like a missed opportunity in my opinion.
Also, the story seemed to be trying to use a panther motif throughout the story to portray Almudena’s imposter syndrome towards her identity has half Guatemalan, but I feel like it wasn’t used enough to actually register with me until after re-reading the story.
However, I don’t think this book is all horrible, I think the story showed the steady progression of her building her relationship with her dad, and giving conclusive insight into why he was gone all her life. It was nice to see Almudena grow and become more accepting of her identity, and become more confident overall in herself.
I would recommend this story to those who love realistic fiction graphic novels with beautiful illustration styles, as well as coming-of-age stories portraying the conflicts and struggles of being mixed.